She Did Not Discuss Having an Abortion With Me – Man Charged For Murdering His 9-Week-Pregnant Girlfriend After She Told Him She Had Aborted Their Twins

A 31-year-old man has admitted killing his girlfriend but denied murder as a court heard how a bitter confrontation preceded the death of the pregnant woman, who suffered more than 60 stab, incised and puncture wounds.

Follow our Whatsapp channel here

Stephan Garner is facing trial at Manchester Crown Court over the death of Amber O’Brien, 33, whose body was discovered in the bathroom of the eighth-floor flat they shared in Blackley, north Manchester.

Follow our Telegram channel here

Amber

The court heard that the couple had been experiencing relationship difficulties before the fatal incident on April 18. Their final confrontation reportedly involved accusations of infidelity and a dispute surrounding O’Brien’s decision to terminate her nine-week pregnancy with twins.

Garner has pleaded guilty to manslaughter but denies murder. During his testimony, he described the relationship as troubled and said he had wanted to make things work between them.

“It just felt like it was sometimes impossible to resolve trivial issues. When arguments did occur she wouldn’t move past it, she would continue. I loved her. I cared about her. I was sad about the way things were going. I wanted it to work”
Details of the injuries sustained by O’Brien emerged during the proceedings. A pathologist found that she had suffered more than 60 separate stab, incised and puncture wounds, including 32 to her face and neck.

Her body was found on the bathroom floor of the flat at Somerton Court, where she had been living with Garner. She was naked, covered with a blue tarpaulin and lying in water, according to evidence presented to the court.

The circumstances surrounding her death and Garner’s account of their final confrontation are central to the case.
Jurors previously listened to a recording of a telephone call O’Brien made on April 15 to request a termination of her pregnancy.

When Garner was asked whether he knew she was planning to end the pregnancy, he told the court:

“No, none of it was discussed.”

He explained that O’Brien had asked him to drive her to hospital, telling him she needed to have her kidney checked. According to his testimony, she did not tell him that the visit was connected to her pregnancy.

Garner said he felt betrayed because he had wanted to be present during the scan.

“I felt a bit betrayed by the fact she lied to me about the reason she was going. I wanted to be present during that scan.”

He further told the court that O’Brien informed him during their final confrontation that she had terminated both pregnancies because she did not want to have children with someone she considered a cheater.

Garner said the revelation left him devastated and angry.
The court also heard details of the events on the evening of April 17, hours before O’Brien died.

Garner said he went to a pub in Swinton with a friend, where they consumed cocaine and alcohol.

“We took some cocaine, we drank some alcohol at the pub,”

He said he later dropped O’Brien at her mother’s home before collecting her and returning to his flat with his friend.

According to Garner, the couple began arguing after O’Brien accused him of cheating. He claimed the disagreement escalated and that she dragged him from a chair.

“She was getting more irate. Her behaviour escalated. She was going mad.”

Although he acknowledged that he had not remained completely calm, Garner insisted he had never been violent towards her.

“I wasn’t perfectly calm. I was never violent.”

He also told the court that O’Brien threatened to get another man to assault him, leaving him feeling intimidated. He said he eventually told her to go to her mother’s house.

“I couldn’t diffuse it, it was just escalating more and more. She packed a couple of bags and left basically.”

Garner said he later followed O’Brien in his car because he wanted to settle their disagreement. During a telephone conversation, he claimed he told her that he loved her and did not want her to disturb her family in the early hours.

Jurors heard that O’Brien could be heard saying, ‘we’re done Stephan’.

Garner said he caught up with her and attempted to persuade her to return to the flat.

“I’m in love with you, I don’t want to have these arguments.”

He told the court that she entered his vehicle voluntarily. However, he described their mood during the journey back as tense.

“It was awkward. We were angry with each other.”
After returning to the flat, Garner said he encouraged O’Brien to join him and his friend in the kitchen, but she refused.

He claimed she threw a glass of water at him, slapped him and accused him of flirting with her mother. His friend subsequently left because he felt uncomfortable with the confrontation.

Garner told the court that he left the property but returned at approximately 6.20am. He said O’Brien remained angry and later blocked his path when he attempted to leave again.

According to his account, he felt a blow to the back of his head, which he believed was a punch from O’Brien. He said he turned around and pushed her backwards into a spare bedroom.

Garner claimed that when O’Brien got back up, she was holding a knife that had been kept in the bedroom for renovation work.

He told jurors that they struggled over the weapon and that O’Brien cut his hand during the confrontation.

“I guess it’s a flight or fight response,”

Garner said the knife made contact with O’Brien during the struggle. He claimed the first knife broke before she picked up another one.

Describing the struggle over the weapon, he said:

“We were both struggling for it. I think she put both of her hands on the sharp end. I think both of us have got both of our hands on this knife.

“Then I think I pushed down and it stabs her. I think after that the knife breaks.”

Garner told the court that he eventually took hold of the second knife and stabbed O’Brien.

When his barrister, Ben Myers KC, asked how many times he had stabbed her, Garner said he could not remember.

“I lost control of the situation.”

He said he stopped when O’Brien stopped moving.
During his testimony, Garner attributed his actions to what he described as ongoing abuse throughout the relationship, the dispute over the pregnancy termination and the confrontation involving the knives.

“The constant abuse throughout the relationship, whether it was verbal or physical. Second was her telling me that she had aborted my two children. I felt manipulated and betrayed.

“Her slashing me and trying to stab me with a knife. I snapped because of all this stuff that has happened. When you look at all these factors as a whole that’s how it has made me respond.”

Garner told the court that he felt horrified by what had happened but was afraid to contact the police because he believed officers might not accept his explanation.

He admitted moving O’Brien’s body into the bath, explaining that there had been blood on the floor. He also said he destroyed his mobile phone by throwing it into a lake because he feared arrest.

During questioning, Myers asked whether Garner accepted that he had killed O’Brien.

“Yes.”

Asked whether he accepted that his actions were wrong, Garner replied:

“Of course.”
Garner, of Somerton Court in Blackley, has pleaded guilty to manslaughter but denies murder.

His testimony has provided the court with his account of the couple’s relationship, the dispute surrounding O’Brien’s pregnancy and the events that preceded her death.

The court is examining the circumstances of the fatal confrontation as it considers the murder charge against him.

Share this Story

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.