A North Carolina family is devastated and demanding answers after their 2-year-old son, Er’Mias Mitchell, died during a routine dental surgery.
According to reports, Er’Mias was taken by his parents, David Mitchell and Shardé Sherrill, to the Valleygate Dental Surgery Center in July for what was supposed to be a simple procedure to place tooth caps.

However, during the procedure, the toddler reportedly suffered a medical emergency and tragically died.
The grieving parents said they were unaware of what was happening until they saw an ambulance leaving the facility 40 minutes after the surgery began.
In desperation, they rushed to a hospital 30 minutes away in search of their son, only to receive the heartbreaking news that it was already too late.
“You sat there, you waited, you never notified his parents,” Constance McCrae, Sherrill’s aunt, shared. “You took this baby alone in an ambulance and told them they needed to go to the hospital …?”
Valleygate’s CEO, Virginia Jones, sent a letter to partners and employees this week, stating that the cause of the child’s death remains unknown.
“Let me be clear, we do not yet know what caused Er’mias’ tragedy,” Jones wrote in the letter. “We may never know. While exceedingly rare, unexpected events can occur, even under the most carefully controlled circumstances.”

Jones explained that the team had provided professional care that day but expressed regret over the delay in informing Er’Mias’ parents.
“The medical, dental, nursing, EMS, and hospital staff who responded to Er’mias did so with professionalism and did everything they could to prevent this tragedy,” Jones wrote. “In the urgency of the situation, our focus was solely on providing care. We regret that this prevented us from notifying his family sooner and recognize how painful that delay was.”
On September 25, the family organized a protest outside the Greensboro dental facility, demanding accountability for Er’Mias’ death.
“Actions were unethical and we need answers as to why,” the family’s flyer said.
Greensboro police are continuing to investigate Er’Mias’ death, alongside the North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners.
Meanwhile, the Valleygate team said they were “heartbroken” by the tragic incident.
“Our thoughts are with their family and loved ones during this unimaginably difficult time,” Jones shared in July.