A Texas woman with a long history of troubled relationships has been arrested after prosecutors say she murdered her fifth husband by injecting him with doses of insulin.
Sarah Hartsfield is currently being held at the Chambers County Jail in Texas on a $2 million bond following a grand jury indictment in February 2023. Prosecutors allege that she “intentionally and knowingly caused the death” of her husband, Joseph Hartsfield, by administering dangerous amounts of insulin and delaying a call to emergency services.

At first, Joseph’s obituary claimed he died from complications of a stroke. But investigators soon uncovered evidence pointing to insulin poisoning. Multiple insulin pens were found beside his bed, and inconsistencies in Sarah’s statements deepened suspicions.
Her first husband, a high school sweetheart, claimed she threatened him during their separation, warning him he “might not survive” their divorce.
In her second marriage, she was arrested for assaulting her husband, though charges were later dropped.
During her third marriage, she became engaged to David Bragg, who was shot and killed in 2018. Sarah claimed self-defense, and prosecutors ruled the shooting justified.
She divorced her fourth husband in 2021.
In 2022, she married Joseph Hartsfield. Friends say Joseph often complained he was unhappy and even planned to leave her—just days before his death.
Joseph was found unresponsive in early January 2023. The autopsy later confirmed that his death was caused by complications from insulin poisoning, leading to Sarah’s arrest.
Authorities believe Sarah used Joseph’s diabetes as a cover for the crime, hoping it would appear as a natural medical emergency.